Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label National Standards

Traditional vs Reform Mathematics in NZ and the US

The Promised Part II on the Failure of Mathematics Teaching in New Zealand... I really, really like mathematics. I understood it easily at school, came first in my entire 6th form year in Maths, Physics and Chemistry in the mid-80's, and enjoyed teaching it to my boys when we were homeschooling. I grew up to be a computer programmer (and software developer and more). In other words, I moved into a STEM field with ease. Strangely enough, I have discovered that people's eyes glaze over when you talk too much maths. Even just a little bit can be too much. For instance, no one has commented on my previous post: Mathematics in NZ at NCEA Level in a dismal state .  Ok, there were a couple of comments on Facebook , but one of those comments was about the picture I accidentally chose for the post.  Also, I've gone and on about these same issues and more to my husband, and after listening politely, he is unable to comment much and changes the subject. Hopefully this w...

National Standards appear to be a vehicle for environmental propaganda

I've been having a look at the National Standards online, and was not surprised to see that the Standards are not exempt from perpetuating the new environmental religion disguised under the guise of science. This is from Illustrating the reading standard : The students in a year 5 and 6 class are involved in a science investigation to discover how environmental causes and human actions have led to many animals becoming endangered and to identify a range of actions that individuals and organisations can take to restore the habitats of these endangered species. 'Plight of the Sea Turtle' deals with the decreasing numbers of sea turtles in the Pacific and describes some initiatives to prevent their extinction. The information is logically organised, and the text is well supported by photos, a map, captions, and easily identified information boxes. The teacher chose 'Plight of the Sea Turtle' because the text includes a range of features, such as descriptive and...

The Censored National Standards Report

This is the report that Anne Tolley wants rewritten because she finds it politically biased. Education Minister Anne Tolley is to complain to the Speaker Lockwood Smith over a Parliamentary Library research paper on national standards in primary schools. Mrs Tolley said the paper was “unprofessional”, “highly political” and so biased it could have been written by the union opposing the policy. Mrs Tolley wants the paper withdrawn and rewritten. The only "bias" I can see in reading it, is that it doesn't agree with the National Government on the National Standards. For that, it now doesn't exist at all on any Government website. I found it by searching for the name of the pdf and then using Google's HTML version of the document. I find it highly disturbing that this document has been, in effect, censored by the Government because it disagrees with what the Government is doing. Read it for yourself and decide.

Deborah Hill Cone on National Standards [UPDATE]

After being given the fright of my day by the picture on the left (it almost looks like what isn't shown is an adult in a school girl's uniform), I read the article by Deborah Hill Cone (Herald business columnist!) on her experience with National Standards being applied to her five year old. This is in line with what I've being saying all along ( here , here and here )... My daughter was apparently doing fine actually - as far as I could tell - but it was difficult to work this out as all the focus was on her areas of ineptitude . It seems this is what national standards do to you. She is 5. Let me say that a bit louder: SHE IS FIVE. How did this craziness come to be? When I went to see the principal he said "Well there are National Standards now, you know." Just to remind everyone, I have read the National Standards, and I totally disagree with the direction they have taken with six year olds, or those who have completed one year of school. So, it is a bit...

Government thinks we are confused

The Government has launched a last-minute publicity campaign to educate parents about the new national standards, saying people are confused about the changes. No. Not confused. I've read the standards. I also have teaching experience. That's why I'm opposed to the standards. I'm just thankful they don't affect me or my children. Critics of the policy have called for trials in a limited number of schools before the policy goes nationwide. A sensible idea. Test the standards. If they do what they are supposed to, then roll them out. If they don't do what they are supposed to, then scrap them. But no, this Government is hell-bent on enforcing them, most likely because if every school is affected, then it won't be so clear if the standards are causing more problems than they apparently are supposed to solve. Just one more example of the blundering about that this National Government seems so good at. Related Link: Govt launches education campaign ...

What is a Classical Education?

Yesterday I spent a bit of time looking over the draft national standards for primary school children . I was horrified to see that after one year of school the standards expected children to be able to write a "creative" story. The sample given was an example of tortured writing that showed clearly the poor child had not yet mastered the use of the pencil. As is to be expected, children of six (especially boys) typically have not yet developed the fine motor control to control a pencil with dexterity. Any writing attempted can be a slow, painful process. Of course, there are exceptions to the rule, but if we are talking about a "standard", then one would assume that the standard is the level of competency aspired to by most pupils at that age. Apparently not, according to Anne Tolley . Education Minister Anne Tolley said schools should not worry about making sure all children reached the required standards in their first year. The Government was more int...

Five year olds can't hold a pencil - oh the horror!

Oh for goodness sakes! Many 5-year-olds are starting school unable to count or complete the alphabet, despite years of pre-school education. Many do not know the difference between a letter and a number and some do not know how to hold a pencil, principals say. Isn't school where children are supposed to learn that stuff? Not to mention that boys fine motor control takes longer to develop that girls', so, boys are even less likely to be able to hold a pencil correctly for quite a while. So, what is the problem, exactly? They worry that the problem is getting worse, just as the Government prepares to introduce national standards in reading, writing and maths, starting in the first year of school. I'd say the "problem" has been around for a long time, it's just the expectations of what children should be able to do at age 5 (because of early childhood education) are increasing. The Early Childhood Council has acknowledged young children may need ...

Grow Government by testing children

On the face of it, having educational standards for primary aged pupils seems like a good idea. Why not test all children to see if they are actually learning anything during all the hours that they have to attend school to see if they are actually gaining anything of value for the time? Sounds grand! Except, I really wonder what the point of testing the children is? If it's to help parents decide which school is better for their child, then they don't need test scores for the school to figure that out. Schools either have good reputations or they don't. You just have to ask around to find out if a school is any good, and then the ultimate test is if your child gets on with the other children and the teacher and is happy in the environment. Learning, quite honestly, at primary level is really incidental, something that is supposed to happen along the way. The idea of testing every child from age 5 to 12 for literacy and numeracy immediately brings to mind an army...